Skip to main content

Carmen- Vote for your Favorite Scene!

Welcome Students and Teachers to Opera Online!!
Students in the Opera Company of Philadelphia's Sounds of Learning program saw the final dress rehearsal of Bizet's Carmen on Wednesday, September 28th, 2011 at the Academy of Music.

In our final Carmen webisode we ask you, students and teachers, to pick your favorite scene from Carmen. The videos of the top five scenes are listed below. Vote for your favorite!

1) Habenera
This aria has become one of the most popular opera songs for a reason. This sexy, siren song comes from the first Act of the opera, where Carmen seduces the the crowd and catches the eye of Don Jose.




2)The Gypsy song
As fiery introduction to the second Act, this aria leaves you stomping and clapping along with the passionate dancers. As Carmen weaves her seductive spell at Lillas' Pastias she entices the women and the orchestra to dance along.




3) Toreador Song
This aria, full of bravado, is the only song appropriate for the entrance of Escamillo, the famous bullfighter.




4) The Flower Song
Don Jose's passionate confession to Carmen in the second Act, makes the flower song one of the most romantic arias in the opera.




5) Finale

The intense final scene of the opera is where fate finally finds Carmen and Don Jose.






Vote for your favorite scene! If you don't see your favorite listed let us know what you think is the best song/scene in the opera!




What do you think?
Carmen is a very controversial opera that sparks a lot of interesting questions. We've gotten a lot of feedback from teachers and students who left the opera discussing the moral issues of the story. We want to hear your opinion on some of the most frequently discussed questions:


Did Carmen deserve to die?


Who is the "good guy" in the opera? Carmen? Don Jose? Escamillo?

Who is the story about- Carmen or Don Jose?


Post your opinion!




Opening Night Philadelphia!
Want to see Carmen again? On September 30, at 8 PM the Opera Company of Philadelphia is hosting a free, public simulcast of the opening night of Bizet’s Carmen at the historic Independence Hall. Come listen to world-class opera in Philadelphia's most iconic public places. Bring a blanket and a pinic and join us for opening night under the stars! Click here to register and learn more about this performance!



Until Next Week!

Comments

My favorite scene was when Carmen, Fraquita and Mercedes were playing tarot and telling their individual fortunes. I love the colors of their voices.
Anonymous said…
ACR BCMS- Tempo
In Carmen most of the play is singing. Instead of talking most of the time, they sang. That is how they expressed themselves. I think in most of the songs the tempo was pretty slow. But the beats were also fast. Like, in some parts of the song it would be pretty fast for about two seconds without a break. And then in other parts it was really slow. I think the tempo definitely varied in Carmen. Although most of the measured beats were pretty slow with long breaks. So my review of Carmen and the tempo are, it was very interesting and the tempo and Carmen was great and really planned out.
Anonymous said…
Opera Review
CKU-BCMS
I thought that the instrumental elements of the opera kind of brought you in and got you more interested in the plot. It enhanced the opera noticeably. The compositions were suspenseful and dramatic. They fit the opera very well. There were also many changes in dynamics. Without the instrumental elements of the opera, it would be harder to understand the mood at the current time. One very easily-identified piece was the Habenera
Anonymous said…
BG BCMS - I thought visual arts were very interesting. I like how the clothes were colorful in some places but the soldiers costume was a little dull which fits them. Most of the costumes were very unique since I have never seen any Spanish clothes before. The costumes and designs really fit into the opera. I thought it was nice how Carmen wore different clothes per act. The clothing and designs really helped out the opera more. The clothes they wore fit into the scenes they were talking about, like when Carmen was all dressed for Escamillo's bullfight.
Anonymous said…
AFB-BCMS

My favorite scene was the final scene.
Anonymous said…
AMV-BCMS
My favorite scene was when Carmen "gave" Don Jose the flower. It was how she convinced him that he had to love her was funny because he believed it. Carmen also sings a lot in that scene, it is amazing how she can make her voice so loud.
Anonymous said…
PAD-BCMS-

My favorite scene fro the opera was the final scene. I liked it because it was the most action packed scene.
Anonymous said…
JAG-BCMS My favorite scene was when Carmen sang Habénera. It was one of the first times you heard Carmen sing for longer than just a sentence or two, and her voice is beautiful.
Anonymous said…
MIL-BCMS My favorite scene was the gypsy song. I love the singing in the scene it was sutal then a rollercoaster.
Anonymous said…
MAH-BSMS
My favorite scene was the Habenera.
Anonymous said…
ACR BCMS- My favorite scene was in the woods when Escamillo came. Carmen and her friends were playing cards earlier and everyone else had gone.
Anonymous said…
MEH/BCMS: My favorite scene was obviously the toreador song that Escamillo sang. I thought it was really funny.
Anonymous said…
GTBCMS- My favorite seen was definetly the seen when they were in the bull fighting arena. Carmen's friend warned her about how Don Jose was hiding in the crowd.
Anonymous said…
CKU-BCMS My favorite scene is when all of the children go down the steps and pretend to be an army, then the general shoots a gun and the children run away screaming.
Anonymous said…
CD- BCMS
I think that the best scene in the opera Carmen was the very beginning because Carmen made an amazing appearance, and the fight was very realistic. I actually thought that Carmen slashed the other person in real life, not just in the opera!
The End
Anonymous said…
CEK BCMS: My favorite scene was the grand ending. Its so dramatic how they end it. I was not suspecting that.
Anonymous said…
DAD-BCMS:My favorite scene was when Micaela went to get Don Jose and bring him away from the smugglers and gypsies. I like that scene the most because it shows that women can be strong in the face of danger. My favorite character would have to also be Michaela, because she is a brave women. Michaela is also fair with Don Jose, unlike Carmen.
Anonymous said…
TD-BCMS

I think that the best scene in the opera Carmen was the finale. It was really exciting. It was realistic. I thought that she really was stabbed by Don Jose. Though, it was sad that She died.
Anonymous said…
MVB-BCMS My favorite scene was the one when Micaela comes to tell Don Jose that his mom is missing him and wants him to come back. Micaela then gives Don Jose a kiss from his mother. Don Jose gives Micaela a kiss to give back to his mom. Then Don Jose reads a letter from his mom saying that he should marry Michaela. That is my favorite scene because it is so sweet and so simple.
Anonymous said…
WCO-BCMS My favorite scene was when Carmen told Don Jòse that she didn't love him at the smugglers' camp. It was evident this scene would lead both to Carmen's and Don Jòse's downfall.
Anonymous said…
mil-bcms my favorite scene was the gypsy song. it was nice to see carmen and how she can belt out notes like that.
Anonymous said…
GSWS-BCMS: Although the whole play was fantastic, I really liked the finale because it was the one scene that really had a lot of action. I think Carmen did not deserve to die because she could have changed her ways. I think the “good guy” in the opera is Escamillo because he did not kill anybody and he didn’t lie to anyone. I think the story is about Carmen because it really explains her life.
AC FSMH said…
The opera was amazing. Everyone did a fantastic job. I think that the orchestra really made the opera more realistic. My favorite part was when Carmen (Rinat Shaham)sang the habanera. I also thought the costumes were very detailed and interesting. Over all it was a great opera.

Popular posts from this blog

Carmen Blog

WRITE A REVIEW:   Having had the opportunity to see  Carmen  at Opera Philadelphia, tell us what you thought. Be as detailed in your response as possible. Consider using "Wring a Review of the Opera" found of p.51 of your student guide to help organize your thoughts. We will accept all reviews, positive or negative! We simply ask that you thoroughly defend your opinion. In your response consider commenting on the story, the sets, the characters, the music, and more.  With  both options  we ask that you include your:               FIRST NAME:              SCHOOL:              GRADE: You never know, if your blog entry is well written, we may just have to put it on Opera Philadelphia's official blog page. We look forward reading your entry! Happy writing.  ...

Tosca Student Reviews

Students in the Opera Company of Philadelphia's Sounds of Learning program saw the final dress rehearsal of Puccini's Tosca on Wednesday, April 27, 2011 at the Academy of Music. Now that you've studied the opera and seen it, what were your impressions? Tell us what you think and post your reviews here! Did you like the opera? Why or why not? Which was your favorite character and why? Did you like the costumes and sets? Who was your favorite singer? Which singer had the best and most im pressive singing voice? Your review should be at least 50 words or more. Please include your first name, school and grade in your post. Don't forget to support your opinion! Click here if you want to learn more about these operas, the singers in the production, and more! Messag e from the Production Staff: We want to thank all participating schools for their wonderful behavior during the dress rehearsal! You were the best Co-Producers the Opera Company of Philadelphia has ever seen! A...

Otello Student Reviews

Students in the Opera Company of Philadelphia's Sounds of Learning program saw the final dress rehearsal of Verdi's Otello on Wednesday, May 5, 2010 at the Academy of Music. Inspired by Shakespeare, Otello tells the story of a slave who overcomes great obstacles to become a noble general, but is then driven to unspeakable jealousy by a scheming, envious officer in his army. Passion, political intrigue and a fatal flaw are at the center of this intense musical drama that stands at the pinnacle of grand opera experiences. Now that you've studied the opera and seen it, what were your impressions? Tell us what you think and post your reviews here! Did you like the opera and why? Which was your favorite character and why? Did you like the costumes and sets? What did you think of Mark Delavan, who sang Iago from a wheelchair? Who had the best and most impressive singing voice? Your review should be at least 50 words or more. Please include your first name, school and ...